Constructive gadfly
Published on August 9, 2007 By stevendedalus In Sports & Leisure
 

Player

1st yr age

Games to age 35

AB

HR

HRs after 35

DiMaggio

22

1481*

5881

317

44 [age 36-37]

Mays

20

2071*

6319

534

126 [age 36-42]

Bonds

22

2002

6974

445

311 [age 36-43]

Aaron

20

2271

8889

510

245 [age 36-43]

Williams

21

1557*

5573

368

153 [age 36-41]

Ruth

19 **

1790

5994

516

198 [age 36-41]

Fr.Robinson

21

2051

7546

455

131 [age 36-41]

Musial

21

1990

7600

325

150 [age 36-43]

Gehrig

20

1842

7397

464

  29 [age 36-37]





 

* military service                    **4yrs as pitcher


 

The point of this table is to show players in their prime years and the inevitable decline afterwards—with, of course, one exception. Bonds discovered the fountain of youth after his prime years. The 756 notwithstanding, home runs are terribly overrated because many other offensive prowess happen between 11 to 20 ABs that produce a home run. Furthermore, the nonsense of stats that rely heavily on longevity in competition that should belong to athletes at their finest hours takes away from the quality and integrity of the game.


Comments
on Aug 09, 2007

if the game is checkers or bingo tho...

i've been wondering when you were gonna reappear.  glad you did, too.

on Aug 09, 2007

A-Rod is going to break it again.  if he stays healthy.

Good to see you back as well.

on Aug 09, 2007
A-Rod is going to break it again.


I'm tired of seeing players "break it" years out. We need to give them the crown WHEN they get it, not before.

And there's another issue that galls me. Bonds is actually NOT the homerun king, just the AMERICAN homerun king. Saduharo Oh played at the highest level at which he was allowed (much as the blacks in the Negro leagues), only it wasn't MLB restricting his playing at a higher level, it was Japan, and he clubbed 868.

Kinda like how Ichiro will hit his 3,000th professional hit next year at the tender age of 35, while the record books will only credit him with about 1700.
on Aug 09, 2007
Steroid issues not withstanding, there are other reasons why players continue to club dingers long after other sluggers have faded. The main ones, in my opinion, are conditioning and better sports medicine.

Ken Griffey Junior, for instance, is approaching his 600th homerun, and has a mathematical chance to become only the 4th player to reach 700, again, using the proverbial "if". A generation ago, Ken Griffey Junior would be retired and preparing for enshrinement in the Hall after the injuries that sidelined him for the better part of four seasons. Griffey's name has never even been remotely linked with steroids, and in our current media witch hunt, I'm sure if he had even smelled the Binaca on a steroid user's breath, they'd have been quick to accuse.
on Aug 09, 2007
And there's another issue that galls me. Bonds is actually NOT the homerun king, just the AMERICAN homerun king. Saduharo Oh played at the highest level at which he was allowed (much as the blacks in the Negro leagues), only it wasn't MLB restricting his playing at a higher level, it was Japan, and he clubbed 868.


I understand the objection, but then the arguement goes that with the restrictions (both wrong), they did not play against the caliber of players that major leaguers do.

But closer to your point - the howls that will go up when a non-American goes for such a record (in MLB) will make this incident seem like a polite discussion.
on Aug 09, 2007
I understand the objection, but then the arguement goes that with the restrictions (both wrong), they did not play against the caliber of players that major leaguers do.


For years, we were told that Japan league baseball was equivalent to US AA. We judged this by the scant few international games we played against them, but I believe it was an inaccurate assessment. Since Ichiro made the jump to the majors, he has not failed to hit 200 hits in a single season thus far, and is on track to do it again. I can think of very few players (maybe Tony Gwynn or Pete Rose) who've accomplished a run of six straight 200 hit seasons, a mark that, in my mind, is far more impressive than Sosa's 3 straight 60 homerun seasons.

When (not if) Ichiro is enshrined in the Hall, he should be enshrined with his MLB hits total mentioned, and his 1278 Japan league hits mentioned as well. And IF he surpasses Rose's record in the leagues combined, the record should be acknowledged, albeit along with the mention that it came in separate professional leagues.
on Aug 09, 2007

Nice to know I'm still remembered.

"A generation ago, Ken Griffey Junior would be retired and preparing for enshrinement in the Hall after the injuries that sidelined him for the better part of four seasons." How very true such as DiMag, Mantle, Campanella, Reiser.... I suspect, eventually bb stats will be sorted by era; for, there's no way one can weigh 714 or 60 in the 20s to 757, 73 in this new century.

Ichiro[by the way, what's wrong with his last name?] is from the old school a smart bat with eyes. After all, someone has to be on base for the big guys to get all the glory.    

on Aug 09, 2007
by the way, what's wrong with his last name?]


My understanding is that in Japan, they use the player's first name, not their last, and Ichiro has continued the tradition in the US.
on Aug 09, 2007
Thanks for the info. He sure is a great slap hitter.